Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Alfonso Cuaron. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alfonso Cuaron. Show all posts

Monday, January 08, 2007

Review: Children of Men



She would never say where she came from

Where does our humanity come from? When does the face in a crowd become more than just a face? What does it take to get us to connect with someone on an emotional, personal level?

In the terms of a film, where is the line between caricature and character drawn? When does the person on screen become more than just an actor playing a role? Where does empathy begin? When does humanness start?

Yesterday don’t matter if it’s gone

There is a moment in Alfonso Cuaron’s Children of Men where our hero Theo (Clive Owen) asks his cousin why he still bothers to save important pieces of art from destruction. Why bother when in a hundred years no one will be alive to see it? His cousin’s answer: he’s just stopped thinking about it. It has no meaning; it is just an exercise to keep himself busy. Even a task that would seem to be noble, seem to be culturally significant, becomes meaningless when there is no future, no one to appreciate it.

Lose your dreams and you will lose your mind

Children of Men is a bleak film. Set in the year 2027, it’s a vision of the future that brings to life our darkest fears. The human race is dying. The end is not a product of war; it is not a result of global warming or some other environmental catastrophe. The human race is dying because of a flaw within: women can no longer have babies. It has been 18 years since the last child was born and the world has collapsed into hopelessness and chaos. Britain alone can make claims of order and maintained social structure. However, order is a relative term. Bombs explode in coffee shops and illegal immigrants, people called “fugees”, are hunted down and rounded up like vermin.

On the grey streets of London, Theo is just another man in the crowd. He’s an alcoholic dragging through the horror that has become everyday life. That is until his love from a life long past grabs him off of the street and asks for his help. Julian (Julianne Moore) needs him secure travel papers for two women, the fugee Kee and the midwife Miriam (Pam Ferris). For motives never made completely clear, Theo agrees to aid them. In doing so, he discovers that there may be something in the world worth fighting for after all.

While the Sun is Bright


If you’ve read my review of A Little Princess then you may already know that I’m a huge fan of director Alfonso Cuaron and cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki. They worked together previously on both A Little Princess and the highly regarded Y Tu Mama Tambien. Additionally, Cuaron is well known for Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban while Lubezki’s other credits include Terrance Malik’s The New World, Tim Burton’s Sleepy Hollow, and, one of my personal favorites, the beautiful Like Water for Chocolate.

However, Children of Men is different from their previous films. Where many of their past works have hinted at the darker side of life, they all remain bright and hopeful. There is color and there is life. In Children of Men, the opposite is true. While there may fleeting glimpses of a sun lit park or a bright sunrise, the landscape here is desolate and grey. Even if hope is rediscovered in the end, color never is. A world without color is a sad one indeed.

In the darkest night


A world shrouded in sorrow has its own beauty. A man may rediscover his humanity and hope may be born again. The people of Children of Men always seem to maintain a distance from the audience, from each other, from themselves but this distance in ways serves to make them not characters but humans. How can we ever truly know what another person’s motives are? We may never discover exactly why Theo decided to help Julian and Kee, but in the end the why doesn’t matter. His why doesn’t matter, nor does Jasper’s, Marichka’s, or Miriam’s. What it comes down to is that in a world gone mad, humanity still exists. Heroes can be real.

This vision of chaos cannot escape from the parallels to our current society. The story is an allegory made all the more relevant by the acts of terror, the acts of war, the acts of genocide, and the intolerance that have plagued us in the recent past. While PD James’s novel may have been moving when it was released in 1992, Cuaron’s film is like a look in the mirror. It’s impossible to watch without seeing the unpleasant truths we turn away from in everyday life.

What is Truth? Sometimes it’s easier to discover through works of fiction than through statements of fact.

Don’t question why she needs to be so free


Of course in troubled times there is never a lack of films exploring our anxieties and fears. What sets Children of Men apart from the other distopian films of recent years (i.e. V for Vendetta) is how it handles the material. While V may paint a dark picture of the future, it is still a slick high budget affair concerned more with showcasing flashy explosions and Natalie Portman’s pretty face than anything else. V was made to entertain. Children of Men was made to tell a story.

Lubezki embraces a pseudo documentary approach using natural sources of light and allowing the camera to film whatever image its attention is drawn to. In one scene, Theo walks through the woods and for a moment the camera is distracted. Rather than follow Theo, it glances up and gives us a dizzying view of the heights of the trees. In another scene, there is a moment when two officers are shot after a violent car chase. The camera jumps out of the car with Theo but when Theo leaves, the camera lingers on the officers allowing us to absorb the shock of this sudden violence.

The way the filmmakers photograph the violence in the film is one of their greatest achievements. They manage a rare thing: there is no glorification. My biggest complaint against films like Saving Private Ryan is that their claims of an anti-war stance is a lie. They use violence to sell tickets and make war seem something to be desired. For me, most war films dishonor those on the front lines by turning war into a commodity, a source of entertainment.

Children of Men may be violent, it may have deliberate parallels to current atrocities, but it never lusts after these things. The story is one that fully embraces humanity and the images that linger in my mind are not the moments of blood and gore but the images Theo’s pain filled eyes and Kee’s hopeful face. Children of Men is a story not about violence, it’s about the people that are living through it.

While I certainly wouldn’t say the film is flawless, I do think that is one of the best of the last year. There’s a beauty in its starkness and an honesty and poignancy in its story telling. It touched my heart and moved my mind. Lubezki’s cinematography is some of the best I’ve seen and Cuaron once again succeeds in making a work of art into a vision of humanity.

Goodbye Ruby Tuesday
Who could hang a name on you
When you change with every new day
Still I'm gonna miss you.

Sunday, November 05, 2006

Review: A Little Princess (1995)

Originally posted on 11/03/06 at Epinions



Did you know that all women are princesses? That is our right. It doesn’t matter if she is poor or old or ugly. Didn’t your father ever tell you that?

Sarah Crewe’s father told her.

Sarah’s story is one that has been loved by generations of little girls. From the novel by Frances Hodgson Burnett (the author of The Secret Garden as well) to the Shirley Temple adaptation as well as several other adaptations (including a popular version for television in 1986) and, in 1995, to this adaptation it’s a story that has awakened the imagination.

Before Harry Potter and Y tu mama tambien, Alfonso Cuaron brought his magical touch to this, a very magical story. Working alongside Emmanuel Lubezki (the two collaborate frequently), Cuaron brings the story to life in the most touching way.

The year is 1914 and little Sarah leaves India for a New York boarding school when her father is sent to war. Miss Minchin’s school is a cold place of rules and proper conduct but Sarah’s imagination cannot be contained. The other girls fall in love with Sarah’s stories and even when tragedy strikes they refuse to abandon their friend. Sarah goes from royalty to scullery maid in the blink of an eye. Kindness, compassion, love, and hope never abandon or are abandoned by Sarah, no matter how dark conditions may become. With Becky by her side, Sarah dances and feasts and, always, dreams. Sarah will always be her father’s princess.

While this adaptation may not be the most faithful in detail to the novel, I really feel that it captures the essence of the story. Between the acting, the camera work, and the music, it comes across beautifully. Cuaron and Lubezki create images that are moving and just plain breathtaking. Liesel Matthews is enchanting as Sarah. And as Sarah walks, the music swells, the leaves dance and even the cold New York City streets seem filled with the magic she carries with her. Every element in this film blends seamlessly together, all working to bring the magic of A Little Princess to life.

Liesel carries the film as the lead but the rest of the cast is just as superb. From Liam Cunningham who plays Captain Crewe to Eleanor Bron as the wicked Miss Minchin, the cast is filled with gems. Vanessa Lee Chester is Becky, Errol Sitahal is the neighboring Indian servant Ram Dass, Heather DeLoach is the timid Ermengarde, Taylor Fry is the bully Lavinia, and Kelsey Mulrooney is the little banshee Lottie. The girls are mischievous imps all too ready to listen to an imagined story or embark on a life threatening adventure. Paternity suits Liam Cunningham well and in Miss Minchin’s eyes you can see the disillusionment and bitterness as well as the memory of abandoned hopes and dreams. Ram Dass is a mystery and heroic in his own quiet way.

What makes A Little Princess so special though is how it is able to transcend the state of being only entertainment. A Little Princess is so much more. When watching you can feel the magic that Sarah and her father talk about wrap around you. It sneaks into your heart and by the ending you are completely captured by this world. Yes, I’ll admit it, I cried. A Little Princess was the first, and one of the only, films to ever strike such an honest note with me. I feel Sarah and her father so completely. This film is a rare thing indeed.

It’s also a family film. It’s intelligent and well done but maintains a sense of innocent fantasy that parents can share with their children without worry. It is a story for little girls after all, a story for the princess in all of us.

About This Thing

This blog is about film and life in the wonderful world of LA. I'm a filmmaker just getting started; I'm navigating my way through the industry, trying to find work, and sometimes even managing to make a living.

I've worked across the country on projects big and small. Everything from an indie in PA shot during the dead of winter to one of the bigger reality shows involving Models and the things they do.

I also just love doing things*. I'm a writer, aspiring director, wannabe photographer and cook. I waste too much time on the internet and sometimes all I want to do is hang out with my dog.

Stick around and chances are you'll catch me writing about it all.

*I use the word "thing" a lot. An inappropriate amount. I can't help it. There are just so many different things to talk about. And I just kind of like it.